Calling Occupants Of Interplanetary Craft: Who Wore It Better, The Carpenters Or Klaatu?


Karen & Richard CarpenterThirty years ago yesterday, Karen Carpenter died.

For better or worse, her voice defined my childhood. Though I loathe nostalgia, hearing her music brings back — not memories, but a sense of what that moment in time was like: the light in our living room on Saturday afternoons, the smell of the hallways in my elementary school, the sensation of laying in the sun in the back of an Oldsmobile station wagon and reading for hours while dad drove us to Disney World.

I don’t miss those moments, I certainly don’t long to relive them, but I feel like I understand that slice of time. I remember it at a sideways glance.

I love “Superstar”. It’s a haunting, beautiful melody paired with shockingly bleak lyrics. If you’ve never really paid attention to the masochism and desperation in her voice, have a listen:

But of all The Carpenters’ songs, the one that made the biggest impression on me is probably “Calling Occupants of Interplanetary Craft”. It shows off Karen’s voice, which was simultaneously airy and powerful, and the jazz/pop break in the middle always makes me dance a little dance (on the inside). And as with “Superstar”, the lyrics are nine kinds of fucked up.

I always forget, though, that The Carpenters’ 1977 version is actually a cover of a Klaatu single that debuted a year earlier. Each has its share of merits, but I have my own feelings about which group wore it best.

6 thoughts on “Calling Occupants Of Interplanetary Craft: Who Wore It Better, The Carpenters Or Klaatu?

  1. Klaatu, surely! although there’s nothing wrong with dear Karin.
    also just listened to Moondog, the 1969 album and
    White noise, electric storm full album from that year and
    Carribean Moon by Kevin Ayers, surely the gueerest vidclip of the early seventies.
    Wow, does that bring back extatic memories of LSD and earliest homosexual experiences on the beaches of den Haag NL


  2. Richard

    I love *This Masquerade*! If I remember correctly, it figures in Todd Haynes’ brilliant/twisted SUPERSTAR — the biopic of Karen Carpenter, told with Barbie dolls.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.